Football
Rating the Big Ten Offensive Lines
By Tony Gerdeman
The Big Ten positional rankings
have been on hiatus while we all got sucked into the joy and pain of
March basketball, but they're back now and I am powerless to stop them.
The Big Ten is littered with
veteran offensive lines this season. In fact, Michigan State and
Minnesota are the only two teams in the conference who don't return
three or more starters. They are also two of the three teams who don't
return last year's starting center.
Similarly, they are also two of
the three teams who don't return last year's starting left tackle as
well. Are you getting the picture? Well, if not, print the following
out, shake it a little, and then maybe you'll start to see it.
1. Ohio State
Starters: Mike Adams (LT), J.B.
Shugarts (RT), Mike Brewster (C)
Possible Starters/Backups: Andrew
Norwell, Marcus Hall, Corey Linsley, Jack Mewhort, Tommy Brown (Fr.),
Brian Bobek (Fr.), Antonio Underwood (Fr.), Chris Carter (Fr.)
The Buckeyes will be without First Team
All-Big Ten left tackle Mike Adams for the first five games of the
season, and will likely plug sophomore Andrew Norwell into that
vacancy. He was the sixth lineman for Ohio State last season and
impressed coaches as a true freshman. Michael Brewster is one of the
best two or three centers in the conference, but he'll have different
faces on his immediate right and left this year. Marcus Hall will
get one of those two spots, assuming he hasn't gone ahead and won the
left tackle job. The other guard will likely be the versatile Jack
Mewhort. J.B. Shugarts will be at his customary right tackle spot,
where he has started for the past two seasons. Obviously, this
offensive line will be a lot better in November than they'll be in
September—but they should still be pretty darn good in September.
2. Wisconsin
Starters: Peter Konz (C), Ricky Wagner
(RT), Kevin Zeitler (RG)
Possible Starters/Backups: Travis
Frederick, Josh Oglesby, Casey Dehn, Ryan Groy, Jake Current, Zac
Matthias, Robert Burge, Rob Havenstein
Ricky Wagner started at right tackle
last year, but he'll move to left tackle to man the spot vacated by
Gabe Carimi. Travis Frederick, who redshirted last season after
starting four games as a true freshman in 2009, has apparently
already earned the left guard job. Peter Konz and Kevin Zeitler are
more than serviceable, as they helped pave the way for a devastating
running attack that focused its attention on running between the
tackles. The only question is who will start at right tackle. Josh
Oglesby will be held out during the spring as he recovers from
reconstructive knee surgery. The time off will not help him as there
are a few other capable behemoths waiting in the wings. Casey Dehn
is a redshirt sophomore with some positive buzz around him right now,
and it appears that he will get the first shot at anchoring the right
side of the line. Even though only two linemen will be manning the
same positions they did last year, this is still Wisconsin—maulers
grow on trees.
3. Michigan
Starters: Taylor Lewan (LT), David
Molk (C), Patrick Omameh (RG)
Possible Starters/Backups: Mark Huyge,
Rocko Khoury, Ricky Barnum, Elliott Mealer, Michael Schofield,
Christian Pace, Chris Bryant (Fr.)
There are only three returning starters
listed above, but it may as well be four because Mark Huyge started
seven games last year—four at left tackle and three at right
tackle. He can probably be penciled in at right tackle. Taylor
Lewan has as much ability as any tackle in the conference, but he
needs to cut down on the amount of penalties he committed last
year—or at least cut down on getting caught. David Molk, arguably
the best center in the Big Ten, has been a mainstay anchoring the
offensive line for Michigan. He's one of the few Wolverines
who still remain from Lloyd Carr's tenure. Patrick Omameh has gotten
better with every step, and should continue his progress throughout
2011. Michigan is still looking for a left guard to replace Steve
Schilling. Fortunately they have a lot of options to select from.
Assuming they can pick up the new offense, this will be one of the
best lines in the conference.
4. Iowa
Starters: Riley Reiff (LT), James
Ferentz (C), Markus Zusevics (RT)
Possible Starters/Backups: Adam
Gettis, Conor Boffeli, Nolan MacMillan, Brett Van Sloten, Andrew
Donnal, Brandon Scherff, Dan Heiar (JUCO), Jordan Walsh (Fr.)
Riley Reiff and Markus Zusevics combine
for one of the best tackle tandems in the conference. Reiff, a
redshirt junior, has been starting since his redshirt freshman
season. There is some concern that he could look at the NFL after
this season, but if that's your biggest concern on the offensive
line, then you're way ahead of the game. James Ferentz got better as
the season went on last year, and he is expected to continue that
trend this season. Iowa is really only looking for a couple of
guards, but they probably already know who they are. Nolan MacMillan
started six games at right guard last year and Adam Gettis started
two, so they both have experience. Both players made their starts
because players ahead of them were injured. And both lost their jobs
when they themselves got injured. Kirk Ferentz was very impressed by
MacMillan at times last season, so things look to be in pretty good
hands for the Hawkeyes.
5. Purdue
Starters: Dennis Kelly (LT), Peters
Drey (C), Ken Plue (RG), Nick Mondek (RT)
Possible Starters/Backups: Rick
Schmeig, Andrew Brewer, James Shepherd, Trevor Foy, Jack DeBoef,
Justin Kitchens
Dennis Kelly, Peters Drey and Ken Plue
were all Honorable Mention All-Big Ten last season, so not only do
the Boilers return four starters, but three of them have been pretty
good. However, despite Plue's 27 starts in his first three seasons,
he is currently working with the second unit and senior James
Shepherd is working with the ones. Danny Hope calls Shepherd a
“try-hard guy”, but don't be surprised if this is nothing more
than a kick in the pants for Plue, who Hope says needs to pick it up
off the field as well as on the field. The only spot that is open
right now is at left guard, which could go to the loser of the Plue
vs. Shepherd battle. Keep an eye on Rick Schmeig, who has started three games
over his first two seasons. Also watch out for Justin Kitchens at tackle. He moved over from the
defensive side and is earning raves right now. All in all, this unit
returns almost intact from last year, but there are incumbents being
pushed, which is a good thing for the Boilers. Now if they could
just find players to block for.
6. Nebraska
Starters: Jeremiah Sirles (LT), Mike
Caputo (C), Marcel Jones (RT)
Possible Starters/Backups: Jermarcus
Hardrick, Andrew Rodriguez, Cole Pensick, Brent Qvale, Brandon
Thompson, Mike Moudy, Ryan Klachko (Fr.), Ryan Reeves (Fr.)
Jeremiah Sirles started every game last
season as a redshirt freshman, if that gives you any idea of his
talent level. Unfortunately, he's out for the spring following
shoulder surgery, which will give Jermarcus Hardrick a chance to get
his foot in the left tackle door. The Huskers had the same starting
five for every game last season. While that's a luxury to have at
the time, it can also hinder development of depth, which might be
where Nebraska is right now when it comes to finding two starting
guards. Brent Qvale and Andrew Rodriguez are the odds-on favorites,
as both got playing time last year, but nothing overly significant.
Offensive line coach Barney Cotton likes the potential of the two
sophomores, but has also mentioned that their inexperience is going
to be a factor this year. Mike Caputo enters his second year as a
starter at center and will be relied upon to keep his shouldermates
pointed in the right direction.
7. Illinois
Starters: Jeff Allen (WT), Hugh
Thornton (WG), Graham Pocic (C)
Possible Starters/Backups: Corey
Lewis, Michael Heitz, Jack Cornell, Tyler Sands, Jake Feldmeyer,
Craig Wilson, Shawn Afryl, Willie Beavers (Fr.), Chris Boles (Fr.),
Tony Durkin (Fr.), Pat Flavin (Fr.), Ted Karras (Fr.)
Jeff Allen has 34 consecutive starts,
and his versatility allows him to move from one side of the line to
the other, depending upon formation. He was a key component in
Illinois' fantastic rushing offense last year, and will be again this
year. Corey Lewis will likely be at the other tackle, but he's
currently recuperating from a knee injury and will be out for the
spring. Lewis was slated to be a starting tackle last season, but an
injury to the same knee that is dinged now cost him his entire 2010.
Jack Cornell looks to fill out the starting unit after starting in
five games last season. Overall, it's an experienced group with a
good history of moving defensive fronts backwards.
8. Michigan State
Starters: Joel Foreman (LG), Chris
McDonald (RG)
Possible Starters/Backups: David
Barrent, Nate Klatt, Jared McGaha, Ethan Ruhland, Skyler Schofner,
Fou Fonoti (JC), Donovan Clark (Fr.)
It's going to be an interesting few
months for the Spartans, who are looking for three new starters on
the offensive line. David Barrent, a 6'8” sophomore, has been
given the first shot at left tackle, but the other spots are
seemingly wide open. Nate Klatt, also a sophomore, looks like a good
bet to win the center job. The right tackle spot should be a battle
between Jared McGaha and incoming junior college lineman Fou Fonoti.
Incumbent guards Joel Foreman and Chris McDonald are solid, but far
from spectacular. Fortunately for the Spartans, they have enough
talent in the backfield to make up for a portion of offensive line
ineptitude.
9. Penn State
Starters: Quinn Barham (LT), Johnnie
Troutman (OG), Chima Okoli (RT)
Possible Starters/Backups: Ty Howle,
DeOn'tae Pannell, Mike Farrell, John Urschel, Eric Shrive, Donovan
Smith (Fr.), Angelo Mangiro (Fr.)
The Nittany Lions are okay on the edges
with returning starters Quinn Barham and Chima Okoli, but every other
job is open. Johnnie Troutman started eleven games last year, but
the staff hasn't exactly been thrilled with him. Add in a DUI in the
offseason, and his spot is no longer promised to him.. Many are
expecting redshirt freshman Ty Howle to be the starting center this
year, but that can be a lot to ask of a young player. DeOn'tae
Pannell will get his annual look on the offensive line, and per usual somebody
else will move ahead of him by October. Donovan Smith and Angelo
Mangiro are two highly-touted prospects who could find a spot
somewhere. The staff is also waiting on former five-star tackle Eric
Shrive to produce like his hype would have suggested. He played in
just two games last season as a redshirt freshman.
10. Northwestern
Starters: Patrick Ward (RT), Ben
Burkett (C), Brian Mulroe (LG), Al Netter (LT)
Possible Starters/Backups: Neal
Deiters, Brian Smith, Colin Armstrong, Doug Bartels, Chuck Porcelli
The Wildcats return nine of ten
in
their offensive line two-deep from last season. Despite the experience,
however, Al
Netter is the only member of the line to have received any conference
accolades last year, and that was just Honorable Mention All-Big Ten
from the media. Guard Doug Bartels began the season as the team's
right guard last season, starting the first three games, and he should
get a long look at the same job again. He already has 25
starts to his credit in his first three seasons. This is a
resoundingly veteran unit, but one that is still searching for more
tenacity and consistency. Yes, 90% of last year's offensive line
returns, but this is also the same offensive line that gave up 40
sacks last year—which was 15 more than any other Big Ten team, and
that's even with a short, controlled passing attack. And we haven't
even gotten into the fact that the Wildcats had the second-worst
yard-per-carry average in the conference last season.
11. Indiana
Starters: Andrew McDonald (LT), Aaron
Price (LG), Will Matte (C), Justin Pagan (RG)
Possible Starters/Backups: Colin
Rodkey, Pat McShane, Marc Damisch, Cody Evers, Bill Ivan, Peyton
Eckert (Fr.), Gregory Lewis (Fr.), Bernard Taylor (Fr.), Ralston
Evans (Fr.)
The Hoosiers return four starters from
last year, and will have a solid group of blockers in 2011. As a
unit, they only gave up 16 sacks last season, which was the
second-best mark in the Big Ten. While no individual lineman
received any All-Conference accolades, as a whole they were a fairly
productive unit, and should be again. They'll never be great at
run-blocking, but that has almost as much to do with a lack of talent
at running back as anything. Colin Rodkey was the backup at both
tackle spots last season, and might be the guy who fills the right
tackle slot this year. Also, Marc Damish started a handful of games
at right guard last season, so he could provide some depth. With a
new offensive system in town, it's going to be up to the offensive
line to get their team's best foot pointed forward.
12. Minnesota
Starters: Chris Bunders (LG)
Possible Starters/Backups: Ed Olson,
Ryan Wynn, Jonathan Ragoo, Mark Lenkuewicz, Jimmy Gjere, Joe
Bjorkland (Fr.), Tommy Olson (Fr.), Kyle McAvoy (Fr.), Luke McAvoy
(Fr.), Foster Bush (Fr.), Josh Campion (Fr.)
Your guess is as good as Jerry Kill's
right now. The Gophers are dealing with a new coach, yet another new
system, and they'll have to do it with possibly an entirely new
offensive line. Ryan Wynn was listed as the backup for every
position on the offensive line except for left tackle at the end of
last season, so he will likely find a spot on this line. Ed Olson
was the backup at left tackle last year, and his brother, incoming freshman Tommy
Olson, could factor in somewhere as well. Kill would like to
redshirt four of his incoming freshmen, but knows that a couple are going
to have to play this year. Fortunately, they have one of the more
dynamic escape artists to block for in quarterback MarQueis Gray.
Rating the Big Ten Quarterbacks
Rating the Big Ten Running Backs
Rating the Big Ten Receivers
Donate by Check :
Ozone Communications
1380 King Avenue
Columbus, Ohio 43212
Help us bring you more Buckeye coverage. Donate to the-Ozone.
Click here to email this the-Ozone feature to a friend...or even a foe.
(c) 2010 The O-Zone, O-Zone Communications, Inc. All rights reserved.
This material may not be published, rebroadcast,rewritten, or redistributed.